De La Rosa, W., Bechler, C. J., Hershfield, H. E., Rino, G., Hatch, R., Chan, C., & Giannella, E. (in press). Management Science.
Many organizations collect income information to assess risk, determine eligibility, and personalize offerings. People are often asked to report their income when applying for credit, housing, or government benefits. This research investigates how different income elicitation methods facilitate or impede reporting. Across nine studies, including two preregistered field experiments, we demonstrate that people have mental representations of their income, often based on salient features such as earning structure. Elicitation methods that are incongruent with these mental representations decrease the likelihood of reporting income, in part by increasing respondents’ anticipated and experienced difficulty and fostering perceptions that they are not the intended audience. In a large-scale preregistered field experiment (N = 31,587), 5.7% of benefit applicants did not report their income when the application used a common but incongruent elicitation (“In the last 30 days, how much did you get paid?”). In contrast, an intervention designed to align with how people typically think about their earnings (hourly or annually) reduced the non-reporting rate to 4.1% (a 28.3% reduction). The intervention also halved the proportion of applicants seeking help with reporting income (from 15.9% to 7.6%) and decreased the median time spent reporting income (from 64.1 to 54.7 seconds). A second preregistered field experiment (N = 26,920) replicated the effects of the intervention. We also demonstrate that income elicitation methods can influence reporting accuracy. Together, these findings identify practical elicitation methods that organizations and researchers can use to improve income reporting.